Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-917693-20150615145204/@comment-25986720-20150617044724

@TisRis:

one song which is popular in vocaloid category does not mean it will be popular in utaite fandom. GigaP's songs are examples. It takes long time for one Giga's song to pass famous utattemita requirements, really slower than other producers who have the fame like him in vocaloid community. The song "drop pop candy", for example, is really popular in vocaloid and odorite fandom (uploaders use the original vocaloid song) but until now, there are just around 10 utaite covers which pass our requirement here (15 covers >10k views to create a page). Junky's Happy Halloween and iku's Hide and Seek (in odorite fandom) look the same. In contrast, orangestar (MikanseiP) even doesn't have his page in vocaloid wikia but here, his songs have been appeared as famous utattemita songs, they are really popular in utaite community recently...

List of Songs page doesn't have much meaning for the one who just look for the infomation of one song (though in fact, there are some songs u can find their pages here but will not in vocaloid wikia). However, it's really useful for the one who want to know more about utattemita trends.

There is one more thing. I have to say that I don't like vocaloid at all and many friends of mine in utaite fandom on our facebook fanpage are the same. Some utaite fans take their step to this fandom from seiyuu/J-pop fandom so that they don't know much about vocaloid. They don't know about the songs until one famous utaite sings and they only care about nnd uploads with actual voices of singers only. For this kind of fans, the List of Songs here is more powerful then what are introduced in vocaloid wikia which just focus on the original vocaloid uploads.

These are the reasons i believe List of Songs should be kept running.